Rum Cake

Rum Cake – A double dose of rum in this EASY cake that’s supremely moist, buttery, and literally juicy from all the rum!! The perfect make-ahead holiday entertaining cake that everyone will LOVE!!

Rum Cake - A double dose of rum in this EASY cake that's supremely moist, buttery, and literally juicy from all the rum!! The perfect make-ahead holiday entertaining cake that everyone will LOVE!!

One of the very first trips I took with my then fiancé was to Grand Cayman where we stumbled into a gift shop that was sampling rum cake.

It tasted so amazing because it was moist and literally juicy because it was so loaded with rum. I had enough samples to likely equal a piece of cake, felt a little guilty, and bought a cake to take home before leaving the island.

Rum Cake - A double dose of rum in this EASY cake that's supremely moist, buttery, and literally juicy from all the rum!! The perfect make-ahead holiday entertaining cake that everyone will LOVE!!

MY OTHER RECIPES

I flew home with my cake, cut into it, only to be sorely disappointed because it was dry, not juicy, and there was hardly any rum flavor. That led me to believe they were literally pouring and dousing the cake samples at the shop with straight rum. It worked though because it got me to buy a cake.

I’ve always wanted to recreate that perfectly juicy rum cake I ate long ago. Fast forward nearly 20 years (boy time flies) and in advance of the holidays this year I (finally) made a rum cake.

It’s everything you want in a rum cake. Supremely moist yet surprising light, buttery, and loaded with bold rum flavor but in a balanced sense so that it doesn’t feel like you’re eating rum. Not that some people would complain about that but I digress.

Rum Cake - A double dose of rum in this EASY cake that's supremely moist, buttery, and literally juicy from all the rum!! The perfect make-ahead holiday entertaining cake that everyone will LOVE!!

I used Meyer’s Dark Rum (not sponsored by them in any way) because I wanted bolder, richer, and sweeter flavor than a white rum like Bacardi can deliver. You could also try a spiced rum like Captain Morgan or even a coconut rum like Malibu. If you test the Malibu option, I would use half Malibu and half of another rum because I could envision an all-Malibu cake becoming cloyingly coconutty, sweet, and off-putting.

The cake base uses yellow cake mix and instant vanilla pudding mix. If you don’t have them in your area, there are plenty of other recipes out there for truly scratch rum cakes. I actually love yellow cake mix and for me this is a blessing rather than a curse that this cake starts off with a shortcut.

Rum Cake - A double dose of rum in this EASY cake that's supremely moist, buttery, and literally juicy from all the rum!! The perfect make-ahead holiday entertaining cake that everyone will LOVE!!

The cake is so ridiculously easy to make. Dump all the ingredients in a bowl at once, mix, bake. After baking, poke holes with a fork over the top (bottom after you invert it) of the cake while it’s still in the pan, add rum sauce, invert, and repeat with hole poking and sauce adding.

I find the cake tastes better as time passes and that it peaks about day 3 which makes it an awesome make-ahead-of-the-party kind of cake. Love recipes like this when you’re entertaining because you can make it in advance, set it aside, and forget about it until the event. It’s the quintessential buttery rum cake and perfect for the holiday season.

Rum Cake - A double dose of rum in this EASY cake that's supremely moist, buttery, and literally juicy from all the rum!! The perfect make-ahead holiday entertaining cake that everyone will LOVE!!

Rum Cake

Rum Cake – A double dose of rum in this EASY cake that’s supremely moist, buttery, and literally juicy from all the rum!! The perfect make-ahead holiday entertaining cake that everyone will LOVE!!

Ingredients:

Cake

  • one 18.25 ounce box yellow cake mix
  • one 3.4-ounce box instant vanilla pudding mix
  • 4 large eggs
  • 1/2 cup water
  • 1/2 cup canola or vegetable oil
  • 1/2 cup dark rum (I used Meyer’s Dark Rum)
  • 2 to 3 teaspoons vanilla or coconut extract (I used coconut)

Rum Sauce

  • 3/4 cup unsalted butter (1 1/2 sticks)
  • 1 1/2 cups granulated sugar
  • 1/4 cup water
  • 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt, or to taste
  • 1/2 cup dark rum (I used Meyer’s Dark Rum)

Directions:

  1. Cake – Preheat oven to 325F. Spray a 12-cup Bundt pan very well with floured cooking spray, or grease and flour the pan; set aside.
  2. To a large bowl, add the cake mix, pudding mix, eggs, water, oil, rum, extract of your choice, and beat with a handheld electric mixer on high power until smooth and combined; about 2 minutes. Turn batter out into prepared pan, smoothing the top lightly with a spatula. The batter is thin, looks a bit skimpy for the size of the pan, but the cake rises dramatically while baking.
  3. Bake for about 45 minutes, or until a toothpick inserted into the cake comes out clean, or with a few moist crumbs. Cool cake in the pan on a wire rack.
  4. When the cake has about 10 to 15 minutes left to bake, start making the rum sauce.
  5. Rum Sauce – Use caution, focus, and take small children out of the kitchen because the mixture is insanely hot and flammable and you’re going to be whisking the entire time.
  6. To a medium high-sided medium saucepan, add the butter and heat over medium heat to melt.
  7. Add the sugar, water, and bring to a boil over medium-high/high heat. Allow mixture to boil rapidly for 4 to 5 minutes; whisk constantly so it doesn’t burn (your shoulder should burn). The mixture should be white, frothy, and fluffy-looking.
  8. Remove pan from the heat and using extreme caution, add the rum while whisking because the sauce will bubble up vigorously when the rum is added.
  9. Return pan to the heat for 1 minute; whisk constantly. This helps cook off some of the ‘raw’ alcohol taste.
  10. Transfer the sauce to a 2-cup glass measuring cup; you will have about 2 cups of sauce.
  11. Poke holes with a fork all over the bottom surface of the cake (which becomes the top when you invert it and remove the cake from the pan). I ‘stabbed’ the cake in about 75 places with a fork.
  12. Slowly pour about 1 cup sauce over the surface, taking your time so that the sauce soaks in; set remaining 1 cup sauce aside. Allow cake to rest for about 1 hour to absorb the sauce.
  13. Invert the cake onto a cake stand or serving platter and ‘stab’ the cake with a fork again, in about 75 places over the top and some on the sides.
  14. Slowly and carefully pour the remaining sauce into the holes. If the sauce has crystallized, that’s okay; just whisk it for a few seconds before adding it. I slowly add some sauce, and sort of ‘press’ it in with a spatula, and repeat. Some will pool down the sides onto the cake stand, it’s unavoidable and okay.
  15. Allow cake to rest for about 1 to 2 hours to absorb sauce before slicing and serving. The flavors marry as time passes and I find this cake tastes better as time passes (about day 3 it peaks). Store cake airtight at room temp for up to 10 days; do not refrigerate. Recipe is intended for those for whom alcohol is legal and appropriate.

Cake adapted from AllRecipes, Rum Sauce adapted from Brown Eyed Baker

Only Eats

Related Recipes

35 BEST Easy Cakes – Whether it’s a birthday cake, anniversary cake, or a just-because cake, you’ll find the perfect EASY cake here! Only the BEST recipes including chocolate, fruity, pumpkin, red velvet, and more!

35 BEST Easy Cakes - Whether it's a birthday cake, anniversary cake, or a just-because cake, you'll find the perfect EASY cake here!! Only the BEST recipes including chocolate, fruity, pumpkin, red velvet, and more!!

12 comments on “Rum Cake”

  1. I was in Grand Caymen a couple of times in the early 90’s so I know the rum cake you are talking about! I think almost every gift shop gave out samples and I bought one too. Your version looks much better than any mass produced and packaged product (even if it is an island specialty). Great tips on choice of rum for this recipe and the sauce sounds amazing!

    • I think almost every gift shop WAS giving out the same samples back then on the island. Sounds like you and I must have visited the same shops :)

      This is definitely a case of homemade being so much better than store bought! The rum sauce…I wanted to drink it :)

  2. I had rum cake only once and still remember how absolutely amazing it tastes! I can’t wait to make this for the holidays!

  3. OMG, Ken is going to love this!! He loves anything with rum!

  4. I make this every Christmas and Thanksgiving.It is the most asked for dessert I make.Guarenteed smash hit.The only thing I add is chopped pecans in the bottom of the pan. It makes a crunchy top and really makes the cake perfect.

  5. Averie, most cake mixes now have ‘pudding mix’ included. Is there a special brand that you could recommend that doesn’t already have pudding mix in it.

  6. Hello — What brand of coconut extract did you use?
    I know they aren’t all created equal, so I would rather get the one already tested. Thanks so much!
    Dory

    PS — Anxious to try some of your quick Asian dishes!

    • I used the Ralph’s store brand of coconut extract. You are right that not all extracts are created equal. However in this recipe, the coconut extract is definitely in the background and not terribly noticeable because of all the rum :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *