Homemade Turtles
I’ve always loved Turtles and decided to make my own.
Everything tastes better when it’s homemade, even Turtles.
Lately I can’t get enough of the pecan-caramel-chocolate combination. Crunchy, chewy, salty-and-sweet.
First there was Salted Caramel and Chocolate Pecan Pie Bars, then The Best Turtle Brownies, and now these.
MY OTHER RECIPESI first made Turtles in 2009. Holy antique photography but I don’t delete old posts because they remind me how far I’ve come and how far my daughter has come. She was in cloth diapers then and now she’s in glittery lip gloss.
The Turtles are no-bake, easy, ready in under a half hour, and you only need 4 ingredients.
I used Trader Joe’s roasted, salted pecan halves. Make piles of about 5 pecans each and top each pile with caramel sauce.
I melted 25 caramel squares with 1/4 cup cream in the micro (or use the stove). Take your time and stop and stir frequently so you don’t burn the mixture and have to start over. The caramel sauce is runny and loose when you first take it out of the micro, but firms up quite a bit as it cools.
After topping each pecan pile with caramel, cover with melted chocolate. I used Trader Joe’s Pound Plus Bars because they melt smoother and easier than chocolate chips.
Some Turtles are coated with milk chocolate and others with dark. On some I sprinkled sea salt to play up the salty-and-sweet aspect. On some I drizzled milk chocolate over a dark chocolate-coated Turtle and vice versa.
Between the salty-and-sweet component, the crunchy pecans, chewy and gooey caramel, and the rich chocolate, they’re hard to resist. Save the recipe for holiday candy-making, birthdays, or for a last-minute hostess gift.
Or just hoard them all for yourself.
The Turtles are no-bake, easy, ready in under a half hour, and you only need 4 ingredients. Save the recipe for holiday candy-making, birthdays, or for a last-minute hostess gift. Take your time melting the caramels, stopping and stirring frequently so they don’t burn. I coated half the batch with dark chocolate and half with milk chocolate. On some I sprinkled sea salt to play up the salty-and-sweet aspect and on others I drizzled milk chocolate over a dark chocolate-coated Turtle and vice versa. Between the salty-and-sweet component, the crunchy pecans, chewy and gooey caramel, and the rich chocolate, they’re hard to resist. 8 ounces pecan halves (I used roasted, lightly salted) All images and content are copyright protected. Please do not use my images without prior permission. If you want to republish this recipe, please re-write the recipe in your own words, or simply link back to this post for the recipe. Thank you.
Homemade Turtles
Ingredients:
25 caramel squares, unwrapped (about 1 heaping cup)
1/4 cup cream or half-and-half, divided
about 16 ounces roughly chopped chocolate, melted (I used 8 ounces dark and 8 ounces milk, both Trader Joe’s Pound Plus bars)
sea salt, optional for sprinklingDirections:
Related Recipes
The Best Turtle Brownies – Super fudgy and loaded with chocolate, pecans and caramel
Chocolate-Covered 7-Minute Microwave Caramels – Never fear candy-making again with this no-candy-thermometer recipe made in the micro. Rich, buttery, soft & chewy. The best & easiest caramels ever
Salted Caramel and Chocolate Pecan Pie Bars – You’ll never want plain pecan pie again! Caramel and chocolate makes the bars taste amazing
The Best & Easiest Homemade Salted Caramel Sauce – Ready in 15 minutes & tastes 1000x better than any storebought sauce ever could
Caramel and Chocolate Gooey Bars (GF with Vegan adaptation) – Caramels, chocolate and oats are combined in these gooey, sticky, sweet, and texture-rich bars
Chocolate-Covered Microwave Peanut Brittle – Easy and takes just 5 minutes to make
Pistachio, Salted Caramel & Oreo Dark Chocolate Bark – Salty-and-sweet & so good! Dangerously easy and make in 5 minutes
Chocolate Saltine Toffee (aka Christmas Crack) – Lives up to it’s name and is extremely addictive! Salty, sweet, crunchy, chewy and a holiday favorite everyone loves!
Cowboy Bark: Trader Joe’s Copycat Recipe – Just like the real thing & ready in 5 minutes. Salty-and-sweet & supremely good!
1/4 cream or half-and-half. 1/4 of what? 1/4 cup?
Cup yes! Fixed!
I know this is probably a dumb question, but when you say square caramels – are you talking the Kraft kind or something else?
Yes the Kraft, or similar, in the clear cellophane wrappers.
I have seen and ate Turtles but not sure if Trader Joe’s chocolate is available in my area, can you suggest an alternative chocolate….would Baker’s chocolate ( that comes in hunks) work? Wanting to put together goodie boxes for holidays and everyone would love these and the no-cook is even better! Thks
Yes Baker’s Chocolate is fine. You want a fairly dark chocolate that melts smoothly. You probably could use chocolate chips, but for these, baking chocolate in hunks is preferred!
These were excellent!!! Instead of using parchment paper, I sprayed cupcake tins with some Pam and they turned out amazing! It was a much easier clean up as well. :) Although I did burn a bit of my chocolate while melting it in the microwave, I added some half and half to it and it turned out perfectly! Thanks for the recipe! I think they will be a hit for Halloween tomorrow!
sprayed cupcake tins with some Pam <--- great idea and glad that worked out well for you! And glad you were able to save your chocolate. Yes, easy does it with the micro and chocolate. 15-second bursts usually is what I do! Enjoy your treats!
I just copied you but mine aren’t coming out of the tin. Did yours pop out or did you have to loosen them abit? Maybe mine haven’t firmed up enough either.
Hi Avery… made these today, when it is cold and snowing at my house. I left them out on the porch to firm up, but even after a few hours out there, the caramel is still pretty gooey/sticky. Is this expected?
I used the square caramels as indicated in the recipe with 1/4 c heavy whipping cream.
Thanks for posting this! I hope my mother enjoys her birthday treat!
Yes if you know what a real Turtle tastes like, the inside has some looseness to it. I mean it should be as loose as caramel sauce, but it shouldn’t be rock hard. I don’t know if you’ve covered them with chocolate yet but that will encase everything and I think you’ll be set! Happy Bday to you mom!! So nice of you to make these for her!
help! Made these today and have learned a lot! need to let caramel cool a bit or it runs all over. My question: even after several hours in fridge the caramel sticks to whatever I put them on…..ugh….help! want to give as gifts but not sure how to give them…..thanks!
Parchment paper is usually great in situations like this.
This is such a good idea for holiday gifts! I have to advise though, I made the recipe as written twice and both times it was a flop (using two different brands of caramel). The caramel is simply too loose, making it impossible to package them for gifts. It’s too loose to dip entirely even. I ended up melting my caramel in the microwave with no added liquid on the third try and that worked beautifully. Thank you for the inspiration :)
Sorry the caramel was too runny for you as written. I have made them with Kraft brand and Werther’s brand caramels and both were fine; but caramels vary soooo much in their composition (how much water, sugar, and milk – if any) is included which will impact how runny or loose they are when melted, but it sounds like you figured it out and glad to hear things turned out okay!
Definitely add the cream to the caramel a bit at a time. Mine, like some of the others, is not setting up when prepared as directed. I made five dozen for a swap, trying to decide if it’s ok to give to others in cupcake holders (because of stickiness) or if I should scrap these and start over?
Just put them in cupcake holders! People will love them, it’s homemade, it’s not from a factory, it’s the amazing thought that counts :) Thanks for trying the recipe.
I made these tonight and they are delicious! My husband loves the store bought Turtles and he said these were way better than store bought! I made some milk chocolate and some white chocolate, as well as some with Score toffee bits sprinkled on top. Yummy! Thanks for the super easy recipe
Glad they were voted way better than storebought! I love all your variations you made! I’d love to sample 1 of each :)
I made these but my caramel ran… What did I do wrong?
It was probably on the thin side and you could have used less milk/cream so that it stayed thicker. That’s my guess. Thanks for trying the recipe.
I just made turtles last night and I tried two different methods with the pecans, the first was clumping the pecans into mounds as your recipe states.
The second method is to chop the nuts and cover a parchment lined cookie sheet with them. Pour the carmel on top of the nuts in circles the size you want your turtles to be and then cool (I cooled mine outside). When cool they easily come off the parchment & then can be topped or dipped. I found the second method to be faster & was able to make my turtles all the same size.
Glad you found a method that worked great for you!
I made these for Christmas and they were amazing! My family said they were better then the store bought ones. I always buy them for my husband but this year I packaged them up for him and he lived them so much I will always make them instead! Thank you!
What a lovely thing to make for your husband and sounds like you scored some points :) Glad the recipe is a keeper!
I made this to take to Christmas dinner today, and I’m so glad I did, they were such a hit!
I made a couple of changes to your recipe, like I used rough-chopped macadamia nuts because I had some that needed to be eaten (they’re really bland when plain!), and I used a tart pan (it’s like a mini-muffin pan where the base of each spot is 1.5″ diameter) which I generously greased with butter because I detest using Pam if it can be avoided.
I also figured out that for melting the caramels, the Ziploc containers with the screw-on caps (the heavier plastic ones, 2 cup size) were almost non-stick and worked way better than a ceramic or glass bowl. I only used about 1 or 2 tbsp of cream for 1/2 a bag of caramels at a time and that was enough to make it runny when hot and it firmed up really well but was still chewy.
Once the caramel was firm, I popped them out of the pan and dropped them into the melted chocolate. I used the Lindt squares because they were on sale at the grocery store yesterday, and they melt into a really smooth, almost liquid consistency. After the chocolate, I set them on a parchment lined pan to set.
I ended up with perfectly round “turtles” and they’re about 2 bites each.
I’m so glad that I found your recipe with the caramels instead of making it from sugar and water or butter as that sounded really tricky & I don’t have a candy thermometer.
Sounds like you made the recipe your own and so glad they were a hit with everyone!
I made these last night and although they aren’t as good looking as your pics, they are delicious! I made half the batch with milk chocolate and half with white chocolate (my fav). What a difference to eat turtles with fresh ingredients!
What a difference to eat turtles with fresh ingredients! = Isn’t that the truth!! Your white choc version sounds wonderful and creative!
Yummy recipe and beautiful pics as always, Averie!
I can’t have pecans, so I’ll have to use almonds instead.
Thanks – pinning!
thanks for the pins today!
I made these when I hosted my first AvaHour and it was such a hit! They were easy, albeit time consuming, but everyone was so impressed I made homemade turtles, it really was worth the time!
Thanks for trying the recipe and I’m glad it came out great for you and that you impressed everyone!
How can I make this without a microwave?
Melt everything on on the stovetop.
I made these the other day and it turned out perfect. I used about a bag and half of caramels and then 2 cups of chocolate pellets and that made about 40 turtles for me. Was great for a father’s day gift.
Thanks for trying the recipe and glad it came out great for you! What a lovely gift!
OMG. I love turtles. Thank you!
I made these today and couldn’t be happier as they turned out perfect! I used the Trader Joe’s roasted salted pecans but had to use 2-8oz packages as there were a lot of broken pieces but they’re great. I used dark chocolate & the caramels from Nuts.com and both are fabulous & I highly recommend!! I only used 1/2 of a 1/8 cup measuring cup to their 25 caramels & the consistency was perfect. I measured both caramel and chocolate more like how I thought they should look & topped them off with Maldons Sea salt flakes.. they look perfect & everyone loved them. Thanks for this great recipe & mine set up in no time without putting them in the cold.
Thanks for trying the recipe and I’m glad it came out great for you!
I love this recipe. Turtle’s are my husband’s fave’s.
I am really writing you just say how sweet you are to have commented on everyone’s comment’s. I think that say’s a lot about the person you are.
Wow that is really nice of you to notice that I reply to all my comments! I feel like if someone took the time to buy the ingredients, make the recipe, and came back to tell me how it went, the least I can say is great job and thank you for trying the recipe! I wouldn’t have a website without readers like you who did just that as well. Thank you for taking the time :)
I just made these for mothers day after she mentioned liking turtles. This recipe really is easy. I followed it just as written. They came out with caramel bits instead of the squares, just like the morsels so I used those and it cut down on the microwave time and it prevented me from burning the caramel which I was concerned about. I put them in my deep freezer on wax paper so I’m hoping when I get up in the morning that they will come off the paper. I tried one and it was delicious. Thank you for sharing this recipe. I hope I never lose it!
Thanks for the 5 star review and glad this was a success!